Bagelafe Menu
35 items in 7 sections · $2.50 – $18.00 · Cafe in Bethpage, NY
Bagelafe’s menu lists 35 dishes and drinks, grouped into Specialty Eggs, Jalapeno Shack Menu, Chef's Specials, Build Your Own Breakfast, From the Griddle, and Between Bread and more. Prices range from $2.50 to $18.00, and a typical item costs about $8.99. Popular choices include Meat Lovers, 3 Soft Tacos, BYO Croissant, Chocolate Chip Pancakes, and BQE.
Specialty Eggs 5
- Meat Lovers$15.00
A carnivore's dream packed with pepperoni, crispy bacon, savory sausage, topped with cheese.
- Veggie Omelette$13.50
Onions, peppers, mushrooms, and spinach.
- Classic Omelette$11.50
Unadorned yet delicious, our simple omelette offer fresh whisked eggs cooked to perfection.
- Desi Omelette$13.50
A blend of fresh eggs spiced with turmeric, cumin, and chili, filled with sautéed onions and tomatoes.
- Western Omelette$14.50
Sujuk, Onions and Peppers, Tomato, Avocado
Jalapeno Shack Menu 8
- 3 Soft Tacos$8.99
600 - 980 Cal. Miss Taco Tuesday's? Don't worry- build them just like grandma' used to with your choice of protein, rice, beans, toppings, our homemade salsas and don't forget to make 'em saucy!
- 3 Hard Tacos$8.99
600 - 980 Cal. Miss Taco Tuesday's? Don't worry- build them just like grandma' used to with your choice of protein, rice, beans, toppings, our homemade salsas and don't forget to make 'em saucy!
- Popcorn Chicken$6.99
- Shack Style Fries$8.99
720 - 1080 Cal. We can't help ourselves- everything tastes better over fries, right? Build it, stack it, kill it! Start off with our tender meat options, toss some beans on there, crisp toppings, mind-blowing salsas, and our homemade sauces
- Burrito Bowl$8.99
720 - 1080 Cal. Build a mouthwatering bowl loaded with your choice of meat, rice, beans, fresh toppings, flavorful salsas, and finger-licking sauces.
- Burrito$8.99
450 - 800 Cal. Build your burrito with a soft, warm tortilla stuffed with tender steak, chipotle chicken, or yummy ground beef, rice, momma-style beans, classic toppings, zesty salsas, and our special homemade sauces.
- Nacho Bowl$8.99
750 - 1280 Cal. Nachos, cheese, meat, fresh toppings, creamy sauces, and yummy salsas means... Mind Blown!
- Quesadilla$8.99
920 - 1190 Cal. Go traditional with just steak and cheese or modernize it with toppings galore- either way, you cant go wrong! Build yourself a warm, cheesy quesadilla with your choice of protein, rice, beans, delightful toppings, fresh sal
Chef's Specials 4
- ZK$14.50
Bacon, Sujuk, Eggs, Cheese, Chipotle Mayo and House Made Hot Sauce on a Kaiser Roll
- Grand Slam Platter$18.00
2 fried eggs, 2 strips of Bacon, 2 hashbrown, 2 pancakes and fruit
- Anda Paratha Roll$10.00
Desi style eggs wrapped in a fresh paratha
- The OFA$14.50
Kaiser Roll loaded with Bacon, two fried eggs, double cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, ketchup, mayo and a hashbrown
Build Your Own Breakfast 4
- BYO Croissant$3.50
- BYO Wrap$3.00
- BYO Kaiser Roll$2.50
- BYO Bagel$2.50
From the Griddle 3
- Chocolate Chip Pancakes$13.50
Buttermilk pancakes bursting with melty semi-sweet chocolate chips for a heavenly start to your day.
- Nutella French Toast$16.50
Brioche French Toast dressed with housemade Nutella sauce and topped with Strawberries
- Brioche French Toast$15.00
Thick slices of rich brioche soaked in custard, pan-fried to golden perfection for a luxurious treat.
Between Bread 5
- BQE$14.50
Layers of pepperoni, salami, bologna & provoloni cheese, complemented by sautéed onions and peppers, with our pesto mayo on a fresh hero.
- BLT$11.50
A timeless favorite with fresh arugula, tomatoes, and smoky bacon between a toasted hero.
- Roast Beef Sandwich$14.50
Roast Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Sauteed Onions, Mayo and Spicy Mustard
- Spicy Tuna$14.50
Albacore tuna spiced with chili and pickle, nestled with fresh arugula and ripe tomatoes.
- Pastrami Sandwich$14.50
Pastrami, Coleslaw, Spicy Mayo on Rye Bread
Coffee 6
- Americano$4.00
- Cappuccino$5.00
- Black Coffee$3.00
- Latte$5.00
- Karak Chai$2.50
- Decaf$3.00
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated June 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.